- ReyJavikVI has been around a bit, so he was pulling people's legs.
- "finally"? no, there have been plenty of logical anti-ebmid responses, including the essence of this one, but they get lost in the billion iterations of the billion-post topics. still, i agree bover_87 does a good job here, and is succinct. it's a good idea for him to do that in Answers, since a giant, circular argument can't erupt there.